23 Godmother Gifts for The Special Second Mom (2021)

  • BY Editorial Staff
  • September 5, 2021
23 Godmother Gifts for The Special Second Mom (2021)

For her new role as a second mother, you want to find the best godmother gifts that are thoughtful and sincere. The things to buy for her need to reflect the way she will guide and support her godchild.

From personalized presents to heartfelt art, get her something that’ll show how much you care! This wonderful list truly has everything you need for this very special lady. Read on and have fun shopping!   


To My Godmother Desktop Plaque: godmother keepsake gifts

To My Godmother Desktop Plaque


Personalized with a touching photo, this godmother picture frame gift has a soft and gentle look. With a sweet floral design, it’s desk art she’ll adore. Let her know she’s the best! This charming keepsake will speak to her heart and soul.


The Night You Became My Godmother Star Map: godmother keepsake gifts

The Night You Became My Godmother Star Map


Creative and magical gift ideas for a godmother are always appreciated. A lovely star map print will show her that she’s a special part of the family. This custom sentimental wall art is out of this world! It’s perfect for a loving and caring lady.


Fairy Mother Mug: fairy godmother gifts

Fairy Godmother Mug


Here’s a fantastic fairy godmother gift! This mug is a delightful way to tell a woman how magical she is with every sip she takes. It’s a colorful coffee cup that will bring a lighthearted touch to the breakfast table. Make her smile with this fairy tale design!


I Really Am So Lucky Canvas: godmother present

I Really Am So Lucky Canvas


This gift for the godmother from the baby is as sweet and charming as anything gets. Not only is this print cute, but it’s unique! Customize it with a child’s name and tender photo for a wonderful piece that can’t be beaten!


Godmother Bracelet: gift ideas for godmother

Godmother Bracelet


For the godmother-to-be, beautiful jewelry is always ideal. This stainless steel bangle bracelet has a classic look that any Christian woman will love. It’s a great religious option for the godmother asking gifts. She’ll truly treasure this wonderful and elegant piece.


The Best Godmother Belongs To Me Plaque: godmother present

The Best Godmother Belongs To Me Plaque


Sentimental gifts show a special kind of love. From godchild to the godmother, this personalized photo art is no exception. It’s a charming ornament for any desk or shelf. Let the second mother know how important she is with this beautiful and touching plaque! It’s great for the home or office.


Just Always Remember This Wall Art: godmother present

Just Always Remember This Wall Art


The bond between a godmother and a child is special. Let this custom photo print reflect such a deep and true love! This wall decor will fill her home with warmth and charm. It’s perfect for birthdays, Christmas, Mother’s Day, or any occasion.


Best Godmother Ever T-Shirt: best godmother gifts

Best Godmother Ever T-Shirt


Are you looking for something casual and cool? This t-shirt is perfect for Mother’s Day or any day! Available in a variety of hues, find one for your god mom in her favorite color. She’ll love wearing this cute and sweet keepsake!


Godmother Proposal Necklace: present for godmother

Godmother Proposal Necklace


“Will you be my godmother”? When it’s time to ask this question, do it in style! Say it with this necklace, and honor her with a unique gift she’ll adore. Available in sterling silver or yellow gold, it’s a surprise that comes from the heart!


Godmothers Are A Blessing: present for godmother

Godmothers Are A Blessing


When you want to give her something sentimental, there’s no better gift idea than this photo frame! From godson or goddaughter to a loving godmother, honor this strong bond with a personalized touch. It’s a great way to show how much you care.


Wine Glass

Wine Glass


Birthday gift ideas for a godmother always go better with wine! This customized design is a fun way to send that precious woman in your life something special. It’s time to party! Let her celebrate in style with this handmade glass. Cheers to an amazing lady!


: gift ideas for godmother

Heart-Shaped Constellation Map


Are you at a loss when it comes to finding the perfect present for a godmother? Look to the stars! You can’t go wrong with this custom constellation map print. Personalized with text, it’s a stellar way to show her some love.


Ceramic Ornament: fairy godmother gifts

Ceramic Ornament


Personal godmother gifts for Christmas are always a hit! This keepsake ornament is a sweet and cheap way to show a wonderful woman some love. Every year she’ll take great pride in putting it on her tree. Timeless and true, it’s a heartfelt treasure.


You Are Nothing Short Of Amazing Mug

You Are Nothing Short Of Amazing Mug


Are you shopping for something simple and cute? This ceramic coffee cup has got you covered! It’s a colorful mug that honors someone who’s amazing and one of a kind! Put a smile on her face with this touching godmother present.


Birthstone Keychain: fairy godmother gifts

Birthstone Keychain


In the gift ideas for the godmother category, religious items often take the cake. This golden keychain is a great example of such a piece. Unique and special, it’s a wonderful way for your favorite lady to carry your love around wherever she goes!


Baby's Handprint Photo Frame: best godmother gifts

Baby’s Handprint Photo Frame


Is it time to ask someone to be your newborn child’s godmother? This DIY custom gift is a great way to do so! It’s a handmade treasure that’s filled with love. Is there a better way to honor a wonderful woman than with this photo frame?


Godmother with Sentiment Angel Figurine: present for godmother

Godmother with Sentiment Angel Figurine


For a god mommy who likes trinkets, you can’t go wrong with a special angel figurine. Honor her with this charming gift! It’s an inexpensive way to send a beautiful message to a wonderful woman. This home decor will look great in any room!


Godmother Definition Candle: gift ideas for godmother

Godmother Definition Candle


From goddaughter or godson to a fantastic godmother, this candle is an ideal option. Perfect for Christmas, a birthday, Mother’s Day, and more, it’s a thoughtful gift that will make her smile. Give the lovely lady in your life a special present she’ll adore!


Ring Dish: godmother keepsake gifts

Ring Dish


When it comes to godmother keepsake gifts, this ring holder is a masterpiece! If she’s a jewelry lover, it’s a must-have handmade present. Imagine how happy she’ll be whenever she sets her jewels and gems on this glazed clay art!


My Godparents Custom Name Canvas: godmother keepsake gifts

My Godparents Custom Name Canvas


For Godparent’s Day, you want to find a gift that’s heartfelt and caring. This unique wall art is a personalized way to say thank you. Any godmother will love this elegant piece. It’s a wonderful display of affection and appreciation.


Birthstone Earrings: best godmother gifts

Birthstone Earrings


Godmother gifts are always more fun when jewelry is involved. These birthstone earrings are a wonderful celebration of life and love! Any woman will adore this simple yet stunning design. What better way is there to say how much you care? Pick up a pair today!


Will You Be My Godmother Box

Will You Be My Godmother Box


The present for the godmother category is filled with many treasures. However, this one is different. Packed with a wonderful assortment of goodies, it’s a special box of unique fun that can’t be beaten! Imagine the surprise on her face when she opens this cool and amazing gift.


Tote Bag

Tote Bag


If you’re looking for a godmother’s birthday gift that’s full of style, here it is! Personalized with a year, it’s a handmade cotton tote bag that’s designed with beauty in mind. Show your love with this trendy and helpful gift. She’ll adore its artful allure!

A wonderful woman deserves something special that expresses your wholehearted appreciation. These gift ideas will definitely take care of that. From functional and fun to beautiful and true, you’ll find whatever you need to make her feel loved!



Sign up for the 365Canvas newsletter.

Get notified of the best gift ideas to surprise your loved ones on special occasions.